Pacifier Baby

The 5 Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Are you on the search for the best pacifier for your breastfed baby? With so many different types of pacifiers on the market, it can feel daunting to choose the “right” one for your baby. Along with the shopping, there are the general worries about using a pacifier with a breastfed baby. However, I’ve done the research for you, so rest assured that there is a safe, breastfeeding-friendly option for your little one.

Why do you need a pacifier? The number one reason is that it will be a sanity saver for mom and dad! A pacifier essentially works to “pacify” a baby. Pacifiers help babies soothe themselves by allowing them to use the sucking motion.

Pacifiers come in handy when your baby is crying because of discomfort or to help your baby fall asleep. Plus, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends using a pacifier to help reduce the risk of SIDS. Using a pacifier also means it is less likely your baby will be a thumb sucker – it is much easier to get rid of a pacifier than to break a thumb sucking habit!

Things to Consider When Shopping

While I am highlighting the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, it should be noted that each of these pacifiers may also be used with bottle-fed babies. When shopping for a pacifier for a breastfed baby, you should look for a pacifier with a more rounded nipple shape and one that has more give in the nipple. In addition, I focused on these four different factors:

· Quality of materials – The pacifier you choose should be BPA free and preferably made of silicone.

· Comfort – Choose a pacifier that is more soft and able to bend rather than one that is stiff and solid. This is especially important for breastfed babies as it should somewhat mimic a mother’s nipple.

· Durability – The pacifier should be designed to withstand everyday use and then some.

· Ease of Care – Consider how you will need to clean the pacifier. Can it be washed in the dishwasher? Can it be sterilized? Or is it hand-wash only?

Philips AventSoothie Pacifier

Philips AventSoothie Pacifier
  • Endorsed by hospitals
  • Made of hospital-grade silicone
  • Durable, but flexible
  • May be washed in the dishwasher
  • It may rest uncomfortable on your baby’s nose
  • You cannot attach a pacifier connector

Price $$​ 

The Philips AventSoothie Pacifier is the most recognized pacifier as it is endorsed by hospitals. My hospital even sent us home with a set of these wonderful pacifiers! It is shaped and sized perfectly for your baby’s mouth.

It is a one-piece design made of hospital-grade silicone. You can tell that it is durable just from touching it. However, it is also comfortable as the nipple is flexible, but it won’t become bent after use. In addition, these pacifiers are easy to clean. They may be sterilized and washed in a dishwasher.

WubbaNub Infant Pacifier

WubbaNub Infant Pacifier
  • Made with the Soothie pacifier
  • Used in hospitals
  • May be washed in the laundry machine
  • A variety of animals to choose from (giraffe, elephant, monkey, lion, etc.)
  • Expensive
  • Cannot be washed quickly

Price $​$ 

The WubbaNub Infant Pacifier takes the Soothie Pacifier up a step by combining it with an adorable stuffed animal. Babies love these things! And, let’s just admit it, moms do too. Why? Because the combination of an excellent pacifier and a cuddly animal is cute and comforting.

The pacifier is attached to the stuffed animal, which does make it a little more difficult to clean. However, the design of the actual pacifier allows for easy cleaning since it is one piece. To clean the pacifier and the stuffed animal, you simply place it in a mesh bag in the laundry machine.

The biggest downside of the WubbaNub is the price. For the price of one WubbaNub, you could purchase several other pacifiers. Also, if you lose one (and it will happen), you will have to replace it.

First Years Gumdrop Newborn Pacifier

First Years Gumdrop Newborn Pacifier
  • Made of high quality materials
  • BPA free and Latex free
  • Easy to sterilize and clean
  • Shaped to fit around a baby’s nose
  • May be sized too big for some babies
  • A little harder than other brands

Price: $

The First Years Gumdrop Pacifier is also a popular pacifier for breastfed babies. It stands out because it is not only made of high quality materials such as silicone, it is also BPA free and latex free. It is also a one-piece design, but its shape is designed to fit around the bottom of a baby’s nose.

This pacifier is easy to sterilize and clean. It is also has a flexible nipple and is durable. Many moms swear by this pacifier because they found their breastfed babies took to it easily but did not suffer from nipple confusion. Another perk is that this pacifier may be used with a pacifier connector unlike other brands.

NUK Newborn 100% Silicone Orthodontic Pacifier

NUK Newborn 100% Silicone Orthodontic Pacifier
  • Orthodontic
  • 100% silicone and BPA free
  • Easy to clean
  • Shaped to fit around baby’s nose
  • Uncomfortable nipple shape

Price $​$$

The NUK Newborn Orthodontic Pacifier is another excellent choice because it is designed with your baby’s dental future in mind. It provides the same soothing relief while also fitting into your baby’s natural palate.

This pacifier is also designed to fit comfortably under your baby’s nose. It is made of 100% silicone and is a one-piece design that is easy to clean. Its durable materials and shape ensure it is long-lasting.

MAM Night Glow in the Dark Silicone Pacifier

MAM Night Glow in the Dark Silicone Pacifier
  • Glow in the dark feature
  • Orthodontic
  • Silicone SkinSoft nipple
  • BPA free
  • Comfortable shape and nipple
  • A little more expensive than other brands
  • Glow in the dark feature does not last all night

Price $​$$

These pacifiers are unique in that they use the MAM silicone SkinSoft nipple which feels much more natural. In addition to this unique nipple texture, the outer construction is made of glow-in-the-dark materials making it easy to find in the nighttime. I love this feature!

This pacifier is also shaped to fit your baby’s mouth and under the nose making it comfortable. The orthodontic shaped nipple works to help prevent future dental concerns. They are easy to sterilize and clean.

Additional Pacifiers to Consider:

Nuby Ortho Soft Flex Pacifier – Designed specifically to mimic the motion of a mother’s nipple

TommeeTippee Closer to Nature Fun – Playful, fun designs with an orthodontic shape

Mustachifier– Why not? Parents deserve some laughs.

To Wrap Up:

Pacifiers can be wonderful ways to help soothe your baby and you should not worry about a pacifier causing nipple confusion. However, breastfeeding mothers are discouraged from introducing a pacifier before 3-4 weeks or until breastfeeding is established. Additionally, pediatricians do not recommend the use of a pacifier past age 2.

Remember, all babies are different. You may have to try multiple pacifiers to find the one that your little will take. It is also a good idea to stock up on the type your baby loves. Buy enough to keep them in all the places your baby is likely to need soothing – the car, the crib, the changing table, and extra for your diaper bag.

Which pacifier does your breastfed baby love? Let us know in the comments.